Best Ice Fishing Boots 2019 – Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

The thing about ice fishing boots is that they’re nothing like your normal winter boots. And it’s this particular reason that makes looking for the best ice fishing boots a complicated task.

But when you have an article like this guiding you through the selection process, you need not worry about anything.

Both traditional fishing and ice fishing are fun activities. But in the case of the latter, you need to make it a point to put on the right kind of equipment. Failing to do so makes it incredibly difficult to sustain the chilly temperature for a long time.

So if you want to make the experience more enjoyable and pleasant, then it’s time to get to know the top picks of the boot industry.

Best Ice Fishing Boots reviews

Top 10 Best Ice Fishing Boots 2019 Reviews

Below is an overview of the best ice fishing boots and below that is the detailed review of each pair. So let’s get started!

Fishing Boots Name

Material

Waterproof

Price

MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boot

Synthetic and fabric

Yes

Baffin Men’s Selkirk Snow Boot

Synthetic

Yes

Guide Gear Men’s Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Hunting Boots

Suede leather with nylon uppers

Yes

Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus III Omni Cold-Weather Boot

Leather and textile

Yes

Baffin Men’s Snow Monster Insulated All-Weather Boot

Leather and fabric

Yes

The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boot (Editor's Choice)

Rubber and fabric

Yes

Sorel Men’s Conquest Boot

Leather and fabric

Yes

Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots

Rubber

Yes

Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boot

Leather

Yes

Muck Arctic Pro Camo Boot

Synthetic

Yes

1. MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boot – The Best Ice Fishing Boots with Maximum Insulation

MuckBoots Men's Arctic Pro Hunting Boot,Bark,5 M US Mens

The Muck Boot brand is exceeding all our expectations when it comes to the performance of footwear. And the MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boots are no different. These have a fabric and rubber construction. That means light in weight and 100% waterproof.

The Achilles, heel, and instep regions contain double reinforcements. These make up the vulnerable spots that need such kind of layered protection to offer maximum durability against harsh cold. (Ice fishing safety tips)

The MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boots carry a17-inch height. This design does an excellent job at preventing snow from entering the boots. And that, in turn, keeps your feet dry and warm despite the snowy conditions.

They fall into the category of one of the warmest boots for the task of ice fishing. Thanks to the abundant insulation along with the protective support. The boots come with a contoured footbed and fleece lining that ensure comfort along with warmth even when it’s -60 degrees Fahrenheit.

But it’s the air mesh membrane that gets rid of moisture and perspiration. Upon testing the boots, I noticed that the topline has a flexible nature. And that means it tends to hug the calf to keep more than just your feet warm and comfortable.

And let’s not forget about the molded, dense foam midsoles. These contribute to providing stability by keeping your arch in good shape and condition.

If you’re into the MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boots, here’s another piece of good news. They have a steel toe option too. So you know that this pair is suitable for extremely cold weather as well.

On the downside, the MuckBoots Men’s Arctic Pro Hunting Boot doesn’t offer half sizes. This means you might not get the wiggle room you require for thick socks. But in their defense, the maximum insulation makes up for such a flaw.

We Like

  • The boots are easy to wear and take off.
  • The rubber outsoles are oil-resistant.
  • The thick fleece lining offers maximum warmth.

We Don't Like

  • The boot’s top half is not completely waterproof.
  • Your feet don’t get enough wiggle room.


2. Baffin Men’s Selkirk Snow Boot – The Best Lightweight Ice Fishing Boots

Baffin Men's Selkirk Snow Boot,Black/Expedition Gold,10 M US

In the present times, footwear manufacturing companies are pushing the boundaries more than ever to deliver exceptional performance. In that case, nothing beats the Baffin Men’s Selkirk Snow Boots. These consist of eight layers, including a Thermaplush lining that provides extra comfort as well as warmth.

The Baffin fishing boots consist of nylon upper and leather bottom. The former comes with a waterproof membrane that the brand claims keeps the feet warm even when it’s as cold as -94 degrees. And I found this to be true when testing the boots.

Another remarkable inclusion is the modern engineered outsoles. These have a thermosetting polymer construction. Such a composition is what brings protection, grip, and warmth into play. In fact, it’s this particular feature that makes the boots light in weight.

But do you what contributes to adding supreme comfort and durability? It’s the combination of the EVA midsoles, polar rubber compound outsoles, and artic rubber compound shell. So you can expect your feet to be stable and warm throughout the day.

When dealing with boots, the fit is an important factor to take into consideration. In that context, the Baffin Men’s Selkirk Snow Boots are equipped with a Velcro fastening setup for the ankle strap, in the buckle top. What this does is allow you to make maximum adjustments, which means added comfort.

In contrast to the unique features, the toe box of the boots is quite narrow. So this might cause a certain amount of discomfort after a few hours of wear. And the only way to prevent something like this from taking place is to try on the correct size of the boots before buying them.

We Like

  • The boots offer eight layers of warmth and protection.
  • The removable liners make it easy to dry off the shoes.

We Don't Like

  • The sizing is a bit off.
  • The toe box is not broad enough.
Baffin Industrial Compound


3. Guide Gear Men’s Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Hunting Boots – The Best Multipurpose Ice Fishing Boots

Guide Gear Men's Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Hunting Boots 2400 Gram, Mossy Oak, 9.5D

The product name itself states that the boots are suitable for hunting as well. So it’s only logical to label them as “multipurpose.” The Guide Gear Men’s Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Boots are built using suede leather along with nylon uppers. The latter is waterproof, which means you don’t need to stress about your feet getting cold despite the freezing temperature. (Preventing and treating frostbite)

These best ice fishing boots feature comparatively thicker insoles with as much as 2400 grams of insulation. So the barrier between the foot and snow or frigid cold is quite huge. And this is how maximum warmth comes into the picture.

The insoles are removable, so that’s another valuable advantage. And speaking of benefits, you’ll be glad to know that the Guide Gear Men’s Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Hunting Boots come with a mesh lining. This contains moisture wicking properties that keep your sweaty or damp feet dry and fresh at all times.

To sum it up, these ice fishing/hunting boots have earned the highest performance scores so far!

Now it’s time to talk about a crucial factor that enhances performance even further. It’s called traction. In that department, the Guide Gear Men’s Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Hunting Boots are top notch. The outsoles have an exceptional oil-resistant nature. And that sounds like a “stable” quality, doesn’t it?

It’s good news that these boots offer maximum insulation. But the trade-off here is that the extra insulation messes with the mobility of the shoes. So you’ve got to prioritize your needs and preferences when faced with such a dilemma.

We Like

  • The cushioned footbed is incredibly comfortable.
  • The boots are suitable for outdoor activities like ice fishing and hunting.

We Don't Like

  • Too much insulation hinders mobility.
  • The tongue design locks out water and debris.



4. Columbia Men’s Bugaboot Plus III Omni Cold-Weather Boot – The Best Flexible Ice Fishing Boots

Columbia Men's Bugaboot Plus III Omni Cold Weather Boot, Charcoal/Bright Red, 10.5 D US

The thing that makes any pair of such boots flexible is the inner cushioning. So keeping that in mind, nothing beats the way the insoles of the Columbia Men’s BugabootPlus III Omni Cold-Weather Boots perform. They bend in all different directions, thus providing the much-needed flexibility for the activity of ice fishing.

And it doesn’t just end there. The insoles of these best ice fishing boots offer remarkable shock absorption as well. So you don’t need to stress about protection and stability either.

As for insulation, the manufacturer has provided an excellent combination of textile and leather materials. This also means that the boot conforms to the natural shape of your foot. Another feature that you might notice before long is the rubber compound used for construction. It has the ability to withstand rough use even in cold temperatures.

But it’s the increased energy return of the boots that steals the show. Combine that with superior cushioning and seam-sealed, waterproof construction, and you have a pair of the best ice fishing boots on the market.

In here, I would like to add that the Columbia Men’s BugabootPlus III Omni Cold-Weather Boots come with unique Techlite midsoles. These are light in weight and provide long-lasting support as well as comfort.

In the case of the Columbia Cold-Weather Boots, quality is the real downfall. What I mean to say is that they are poorly constructed.

We Like

  • The Omni-Heat lining offers tons of insulation for warmth.
  • The boots deliver excellent impact absorption.

We Don't Like

  • The break-in period is too long.
  • They are of poor quality.


5. Baffin Men’s Snow Monster Insulated All-Weather Boot – The Best High-Quality Ice Fishing Boots

Baffin Men's Snow Monster Insulated All-weather Boot,Worn Brown,12 D US

Baffin ice fishing boots are the only ones in the industry that rank the highest when it comes to design and functionality. It’s because Baffin understands that traditional or regular boots are not ideal for lower temperatures. In that case, let me introduce you to the Baffin Men’s Snow Monster Insulated All-Weather Boots.

Think of this pair as the go-to option for all your ice adventures. The Snow Monster features foam-based, molded inner system that offers three important characteristics. These are warmth, comfort, and fit.

The seam-sealed, waterproof uppers and insulated leather design are the key talking points of the Baffin Men’s Snow Monster Insulated All-Weather Boots. The former has a snow collar, which is responsible for keeping freezing water away and out.

You might find relief in knowing that the boots consist of a speed-lace closure with toggle. This particular component can be easily adjusted to provide maximum comfort. And as for the outsoles, they are outfitted with slip-resistant pads. So you can expect excellent grip even on ice.

The Baffin Men’s Snow Monster Insulated All-Weather Boots do look bulky. But that doesn’t mean they are not lightweight and soft enough. Once you put them on, you’ll know what I mean!

No matter what, it’s important that you check the sizing chart of these boots. They tend to run smaller than the actual size. So please don’t forget to order one size up.

We Like

  • The boots offer abundant comfort and support.
  • ​The quality/quantity of insulation is perfect.
  • They are suitable for all outdoor activities in the snow.

We Don't Like

  • The design of the boots is bulky in appearance.
  • They are not true to size.

The Life of a Baffin Boot


6. The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boot – Best Waterproof Ice Fishing Boots

The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boot,Black,11 M US Mens/12 M US Womens

By my calculation, you won’t find anything better than these when it comes to waterproofing capacity. The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boots leave no room for freezing water. And do you know why that is? It’s because these best ice fishing boots feature double reinforcements, which means more thickness and durability.

Unlike some of the other models listed in the article, these are waterproof right from the bottom all the way till the top. Plus, the boots are created with a 17-inch height. This means your legs and feet will remain dry and warm even during snowy conditions. When boots are that high, they don’t allow muck and snow to enter, right? So that’s a huge bonus point!

Now it’s time to talk about the fabric and rubber construction. Such a design combines with the molded, EVA midsoles to give you a contoured footbed. And this translates into proper cushioning and superior comfort. It also means that the boots are light in weight.

For the activity of ice fishing, you need shoes that offer tons of warmth. In that regard, the thermal foam of these boots provides that additional warmth. And outside, the rugged bottom provides optimal traction, protection, and durability.

Did you know that The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boots come with stretch binding? Yes, that’s right. The top region of the boots offers stretch binding to prevent water from seeping through. That means 100% waterproof!

If you want to buy a pair of the best waterproof ice fishing boots, there’s nothing better than this. But if you wish to purchase boots that deliver exceptional slip resistance, you’re better off with another pick. Unfortunately, The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boots don’t perform that well on wet, hard surfaces.

We Like

  • The boots can withstand daily, rough use.
  • The removable insoles make cleaning easier.

We Don't Like

  • They have a bulky design.
  • The outsoles are not entirely slip-resistant.
Built to Last | The Original Muck Boot Company


7. Sorel Men’s Conquest Boot – The Best High-Performance Ice Fishing Boots

Sorel Men's Conquest Snow Boot, Bark, 10 M US

Let me begin by stating that the Sorel Men’s Conquest Boots enjoy a leather and synthetic upper construction. These two components are sealed tightly to give you that much-needed waterproof protection.

These lightweight boots are six inches tall, which means six inches of waterproof protection. They come with molded EVA midsoles that offer a footbed suitable for long hours of ice fishing or trekking.

As I said earlier, the boots are seam-sealed to keep water away and out. Plus, the integrated gaiter has a unique lock closure mechanism. This particular system adds more comfort and convenience to the whole experience.

Lastly, the thermal rubber compound shell used for the boots is injection molded to bring more protection into the picture. There’s nothing more you could ask for from the best ice fishing boots!

Think of the Sorel Men’s Conquest Boots as the most comfortable pair on the market. This is partly because of the special Achilles strap. Such an element makes lacing the boots easier. Thus, they are convenient to wear and take off. And we all know how comfortable that is, don’t we?

No matter how you look at it, poor durability is always a major drawback. So that’s one huge disappointment with the Sorel Men’s Conquest Boots.

We Like

  • The technical fabrics provide optimal warmth.
  • The boots deliver seam-sealed waterproof protection.

We Don't Like

  • The boots are susceptible to tearing easily.
  • They grip well on all kinds of surfaces.


8. Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots – The Best Ice Fishing Boots Suitable for Coldest Weather Conditions

Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots

The Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots have earned the highest points during the winter season. What I mean to say is that you won’t come across anything better than these to wear for the activity of ice fishing when the temperature reaches 20 degrees below zero.

It’s the insulation of the boots that makes them stand out from the crowd. The material used is wool felt, and there are multiple layers of it. This keeps your feet well protected from freezing temperatures.

And if that wasn’t enough, the manufacturer has added a solid rubber exterior to make the boots waterproof. It gets even better; they feature a valve, which comes in handy during high altitudes.

Now here’s a first. The Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots are original military grade. This means that they have the ability to evaporate water in no time. Such a characteristic prevents the formation of frostbites and cold injuries.

It’s time for me discuss the key element of the Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots. The thick layer of felt and wool is located between waterproof rubber. And the whole structure is compressed to provide a completely flexible, watertight, and thin insulated barrier. So you don’t need to stress about moisture or sweat either.

The thing about the best ice fishing boots is that they provide your feet with enough space. This extra room is often filled with thick socks. And that’s the best part about the Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots. They are created to be worn with thick padded socks.

I found the Combat Boot Mickey Mouse Extreme Cold Weather Boots to be slightly on the heavier side. And this might be a problem if you’re used to wearing lightweight boots. But it’s not something you can’t get used to.

We Like

  • The air pressure valve is suitable for high altitudes.
  • The insulation provides warmth and water protection.

We Don't Like

  • The boots are heavy.
  • They don’t offer a lot of traction.


9. Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boot – The Warmest Boots for the Purpose of Ice Fishing

Baffin Men's Control Max Snow Boot,Worn Brown,12 M US

If what you’re looking for is a pair to withstand extreme cold, then let me introduce you to the Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boots.

Just like the other Baffin models discussed in the article, these too consist of eight layers of Thermaplush liners. So the boots are capable of handling temperatures as low as -70 degrees Fahrenheit. And let’s not forget about the superior cushioning these layers provide!(Ice fishing tips)

Another feature that you might find highly beneficial is the combination of the leather uppers and the seam-sealed design. The former helps in keeping your feet warm despite the snow and ice. And the latter eliminates moisture.

You don’t even have to stress about traction with the Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boots. The unique Icepaw rubber outsoles grip all kinds of surfaces quite easily. And as for the midsoles, they have tons of comfort to offer even for long hours of wear.

What’s that one component that contributes to providing a better fit? In the case of boots, it’s the lacing system, isn’t it? So keeping that in mind, the Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boots feature a D-ring type lace closure. What this does is allow you to adjust the boots easily, so you can enjoy maximum support.

The brand claims that the boots are waterproof by nature. But that’s not entirely true. The waterproofing capacity of the Baffin Men’s Control Max Insulated Boots is not as high as you’d expect from the best ice fishing boots.

We Like

  • The full-grain leather is of high-quality.
  • ​The multilayered inner creates a comfortable footbed.
  • The non-slip outsoles provide excellent traction.

We Don't Like

  • The sizing of the boots is slightly off.
  • They are not 100% waterproof.
Baffin Inner Boot System Technology


10. Muck Arctic Pro Camo Boot – The Bonus Pick

Muck Boots Arctic Pro Camo Mossy Oak - Men's 9.0, Women's 10.0 B(M) US

The Muck Arctic Pro Camo Boots are the kind of ice fishing boots that perform exceptionally well even in freezing temperatures. They have a thick enough thermal foam and flex foam layer. These two components pair up with the stretch nylon to keep your feet dry and warm at all times.

The top line of the boots has that stretch-fit nature. This means they don’t allow the cold from getting inside the shoes. And here’s something that you might value the most. The Muck Arctic Pro Camo Boots come with unique outsoles. These go a long way in keeping you on your feet and not falling on your backside every now and then.

The boots share a lot in common with the other models on the list. These too feature molded, EVA midsoles and contoured footbed. So you need not worry about comfort during ice fishing. Plus, the waterproofing capacity of the boots is also pretty top notch.

As a bonus, the manufacturer has added air mesh. This lining helps in getting rid of moisture, odor, and sweat.

The most striking aspect of the Muck Arctic Pro Camo Boots is that they are suitable for extreme weather conditions as well. And why wouldn’t they be! After all, the boots are specifically created for those who love to go ice fishing on frozen lakes.

There’s one significant drawback though. The Muck Arctic Pro Camo Boots are not the kind of boots you can wear with heavier socks. But in their defense, the integrated foam layers make up for such a flaw.

We Like

  • The boots offer maximum insulation.
  • The fit and quality are exceptional.

We Don't Like

  • They cannot be worn with thicker socks.

Best Ice Fishing Boots Buyer’s Guide

The selection process becomes streamlined after you get to know the top picks available on the market. But the only thing that makes the task of buying ice fishing boots easier is understanding the anatomy of the footwear. Without that, you wouldn’t know how to differentiate between right and wrong.

So it’s time to discuss useful buying tips along with the most important characteristics of the best ice fishing boots. My goal here is to help inform your purchase. So are you ready for that?

Why do You Need the Best Ice Fishing Boots?

If you’ve reached this part of the article, then it’s clear that you too perceive ice fishing to be a thrilling activity. The adventure requires proper skills as well as knowledge, am I right? Using appropriate gear ensures safety and makes the experience not only successful but enjoyable too.

With correct boots, you can keep your feet upright and warm even on cold, slippery ice. But these reasons might not sound convincing enough. At least not as convincing as the ones listed below.

  • Ice fishing boots protect your feet against the icy cold water.
  • They provide the much-needed insulation and warmth.
  • With ice fishing boots, you can expect your feet to remain stable and upright during the activity.

What are the Best Features to Take Into Consideration?

1. Insulation

When talking about insulation, check the temperature of the fishing location. Not all ice fishing boots enjoy the same level of insulation. So if you’re going to be heading to a colder place, you might require maximum insulation. Otherwise, factors like comfort as well as warmth get compromised.

And the best part about insulation is that it offers optimal warmth without making the boot too heavy. But if comfort is your absolute concern, then nothing beats wool or fleece insulation. The trade-off is that they are comparatively heavier than the others.

2. Waterproof

Ice fishing requires you to wade in frozen waters or drill through ice, right? With that in mind, you need boots that are waterproof. So before deciding to make a purchase, please ensure that the pair keeps your feet dry at all times.

You’ll be relieved to know that the majority of the best ice fishing boots has an excellent waterproofing capacity.

3. Size

Winter boots and thick socks are like best buddies. They go hand in hand, don’t they? So if that’s the case, then you should pick a size that accommodates the extra layer of socks. You don’t want to end up spending your money on ice fishing boots that choke your sock-covered feet.

4. Traction

When buying any type of shoes for outdoor activities, traction is a must. It goes a long way in adding stability and safety to the whole experience. And if you’re going to be walking on ice, then you need boots that offer tons of physical resistance.

Snow and ice make up slippery surfaces. So at such times, it’s important to be standing on your feet and not lying on your backside.

5. Removable Insoles/liners

The activity of ice fishing demands you to spend long hours outdoors. This means subjecting your boots to heavy-duty, rough use. Even in the cold season, our feet sweat and give rise to bad odor. So the only way to get rid of all the smell and moisture is by removing the liners of the boots.

When shoes come with removable insoles, you get the opportunity to air-dry them after a long day of work.

Additional Tips to Keep in Mind:

  • Buy boots that give your feet some breathing space for socks. Thick socks bring more warmth and protection into play. So you need to pick shoes that allow these factors to take control.
  • Boots come with laces, right? In that case, look for metal clamps that are located in the front region. Such a design prevents the laces of the shoes from coming off or slipping out.

Also, you can easily open metal clamps whenever you want to replace those laces.

  • In the same vein, ensure that the laces of the boots are thick enough. This makes it easy for you to grip them even with gloves on. And thick laces also mean that they won’t tear apart anytime soon. (Here’s what you should know about choosing thick socks for colder temperatures)
  • Finally, let’s not forget about the pattern of the outsoles. The best ice fishing boots owna tread pattern with enough opening and grooves. Such a composition prevents ice from getting stuck.

And if you want the boots to last for many years, then look for rubber compound outsoles. They deliver exceptional performance in all important aspects.

Watch: Nearly 10,000 People Ice Fish for Charity | National Geographic

Which Best Ice Fishing Boot should I choose?

My Choice: The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boots

Based on my personal, honest, and critical judgment, I don’t see anything better than The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boots. These are considered to be the best ice fishing boots in all aspects.

They provide the much-needed warmth to withstand temperatures as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit. And not just that, these MuckBoots are also suitable for activities like sled riding, snow blowing, and snowmobiling.

Insulated and waterproof, The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boots come with a tall shaft to provide additional protection. And as for the outsoles, they are grippy enough to keep your feet planted to the ground no matter what.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: